My thinking with respect to the use of Flickr is that students can not only upload their own photos to share, store their work, set up networks and so on; but the database and other photo databases, such as PictureIt for example, can be used to promote discussions and activities on various themes, from which deep learning can emerge. For the purposes of this activity, I chose the theme of family and with the limited time I have selected two photos giving contrasting depictions of family.
Photo 1 is entitled "A Dryland Farmer and Family on the Flathead Reservation Near Niriada, Montana", and was taken in 1921 and comes courtesy of the US National Archives. This is a powerful photo - sure they're a family, but what is the photo telling us about their life? Is this the way families are conventionally depicted in the media? Photo 2 is a family portrait photograph, courtesy of Nicholas Daniel - it is not the ideal contrast photo I was looking for to Photo 1 but it is close enough to provide the opposition I was looking for to promote discussion on representations or ideas of family. What factors can be discerned from the photo that makes this family so different to the family in Photo 1 - what clues does the photo give? Further, which photo is closer to representing your (the learner's) idea of what a family should be?
Ideally, in a classroom situation, students could do their own research and find representations of family based on certain criteria (e.g. families like theirs, families not like theirs, modern representations of family, traditional representations of family, families from other cultures, etc); they could work in groups or individually, and then share their representations with the whole class. Further activities could then be designed from this initial activity, particularly using ICT. This kind of theme-based activity would work well in a SOSE lesson or module. It is relevant to students because no matter how their own family is comprised, every one has a sense of family in some way (this statement could be argued against, and I do see the grounds for it, but lets assume for now that children in a school environment have some sense of family or home); through exploring the different representations and types of families, students from non-traditional, blended, broken families, and so on, can identify with many other people in the world who are in similar family/home situations, and those from traditional families can recognise difference, and appreciate that there is nothing wrong with alternative family types to their own. This could be a very useful activity for cultivating appreciation and understanding of the 'other' and definitely promote deep understanding. Please open the links below to view the contrasting representations, and take notice of all of the elements of the images, and what kind of narrative could be created to explain why the family in Photo 1 is so different to that in Photo 2. I will explore this at greater length soon.
Photo 1
Photo 2
No comments:
Post a Comment