Thursday, April 19, 2012

Assignment 2 - Groups 1 to 4 Technologies

Reflective Synopsis
  1. Compulsory Posting: Wiki Activities, Weeks 1 and 2. Please refer to this posting located elsewhere in this Blog.
  2. Selected Tools
  • Group 1 - Wikis
Wikis present great opportunities for constructivist and connectivist learning. The scaffolded nature of learning that the tool affords (see this article on Vgotsky) enables learners to effectively progress from the lower-order to higher-order thinking faculties of Bloom's Taxonomy, which is vital for quality pedagogical outcomes. The De Bono's Hats thinking routine, which I have reflected on in this blog via the weeks 1 and 2 wiki activities, demonstrated how wikis enable scaffolded learning. Of course, this is just one thinking routine, and wikis hold much more potential for learning than just thinking routines. The nature of learning in a wiki is highly social and networked, and in this way it has many connectivist associations (see this article by Seimens, and my reflections on Connectivism here). Group learning is extremely important, partcularly with respect to 21st century learning, and crucial for learners' social and cultural literacy development. Wikis also encourage and enhance creativity in learners, and without attention to this, much talent is lost, unrealised, or wasted from the human intellectual pool (as Sir Ken Robinson makes clear).
In my own practice, I would employ wiki based activities across a range of KLAs to facilitate the learning outcomes mentioned above. The activity would be scaffolded and focused on leading learners to the attainment of higher order thinking, it would be implicitly group based with the potential for linking with networks on a global scale, and it would encourage creativity, not only through the scaffolded learning design it affords, but also through requiring high levels of research, reflection, and multi modal communication. I see the wiki technology as superior to blogs and websites for learners, primarily due to the higher potential it has for scaffolded learning, the greater levels of networking and evaluation it implies, and the socio-cultural literacy benefits it affords. In this it enables students to develop deep understanding, particularly in encountering the 'other', not so much in people of physical, ethnic or religious difference, but in having one's own learning informed by the knowledge that resides outside of the individual, that resides in others. A blog is more of an individual based tool, and similarly a website is an autonomous creation. For instance, in a blog, one can receive feedback, but this isn't as organic a process as that in a wiki, and the reflection would happen empirically or chronologically, rather than informing the product as it is being developed; similarly, if a learner was to set up a Weebly, they would be building from their own understandings primarily, and though it would involve creative and multi modal learning, it would be mainly informed by what was already "inside the pipe" as Seimens analogises. Learning in a blog and a weebly, or website, is more static and doesn't evolve as it does in a wiki.
The legal, safety and ethical considerations must be taught to the learners as a pre-requisite for wiki, and indeed, much online learning. This learning could constitute a sub-unit that required learners to be assessed on their knowledge of attribution, copyright, inappropriate content, and how to work ethically and respectfully in what is a 'communal' learning environment.
  • Group 2 - Digital Video
I have selected digital video as the Group 2 tool of focus, as it can be used across all areas of the curriculum, and will be engaging for the vast majority of learners and learning types, as put forward by Felder and Solomon's model, but more comprehensively in Gardner's Multiple Intelligences. For instance, it can cater to visual, global, kinesthetic, interpersonal, intrapersonal, and musical learners. Depending on the content or topic of focus which the tool is being used for, it could conceivably cater for all learning styles. It is a creative practice in itself, film making being a bona-fide field of artistic endeavour. Even in those students who feel that they aren't creative 'types', the experience of making a movie (however informal or amateur it may be) will engender and bring out artistic sensibilities that the learner may have been unaware of possessing. Digital video can be used not simply as a stand alone product, but can be one aspect of a more holistic overall project: it can be a compliment to, or augment, a more comprehensive, multi modal presentation; it can be used to assist in skill development (such as in music, drama, dance, athletics) and it can be used as a networking tool, something that can link people across distances and present perspectives and points of view that wold be unavailable in other non visual or non-cinematic modes of presentation or communication. Digital video footage can be added to a wiki, a Prezi, a Glogster, and so on; it can enhance individual identity and contribute to social and emotional well being; it can provide students with a feeling of success, and promote self esteem and confidence in their ability to 'create'. Certainly, digital audio and podcasts have their benefits, but digital video can reach the same audiences, and can engage a greater range of faculties, particularly aesthetic sensibilities, than these other technologies.
Caution must be taken in producing videos and, especially within a child and school context, guidelines must be established and policed to ensure the producer and the people being filmed aren't put at risk. Again, these guidelines would have to be incorporated into the learning unit or curriculum. Informal instruction would be too risky, so formal achievement measures would be necessary as a prior or complimentary knowledge. Similarly, the content would have to be monitored by the teacher to ensure it was appropriate, the kind of sites that materials got posted to on the internet would need to be controlled, and the learning would similarly need to be orchestrated by the teacher to ensure learners don't just produce a video for the sake of it, bereft of any linkage with the learning outcomes prescribed for the activity incorporating the tool. As with all digital technologies and e-learning, teachers must not only be competent in the skill required with the technology, but also in the legal, safety and ethical considerations of using technology in pedagogy design, and this is an aspect the TPACK framework (see Mishra and Koehler) which shouldn't be overlooked. But ultimatley, these risks could only be controlled in a school environment; once students have skills in this technology, there is no way of controlling what products they make or risks they take with it.
  • Group 3 - Prezi
After investigating the Group 3 tools, I see Prezi as the most effective learning tool in the suite. Of course, this may not necessarily be true for each individual learner. It is an advanced tool when compared with Powerpoint, for example, but in its complexity it is still based on common and established ICT operations. The final product is the real value in the Prezi tool; the individual elements such as text, images, videos, links, graphics, and so on are relatively easy to create, but the challenge is to create the whole picture through the technological and communication skills one already has. It is not a picture that can be created quickly or haphazardly, and it is this complexity which gives it its learning value and worth. It causes the 'producer' to go deep, and it is scaffolded in its structure. Creating a presentation in Prezi is just that, creating. It activates all of the levels of Blooms Taxonomy, and nurtures the learner's intellect and artistic faculties.
Prezi is constructivist through its scaffolded building framework - it starts small, with the learner assembling building blocks, and evolves into a whole. This 'whole' comes into vision as the construction takes shape. It is connectivist in its networking potential; not only does it allow a user to borrow from other's work if permissions are in place, but it is publishable and accessible globally. Of course, it is multi modal and aligns with the imperatives for 21st century learning. It can be used across the entire curriculum, and definitely caters for the range of learning styles and preferences which have been identified by the relevant theorists. It eclipses Powerpoint, even though the more advanced operations explored in the Group 3 tutorials and engagement show that Powerpoint has learning benefits. Powerpoint could be considered more useful for younger learners, perhaps years 1-4, whereas Prezi could be handled by students from year 5 onwards - with the right instruction and scaffolding. I have only put together a fairly simple Prezi, and this is not necessarily a primary school pedagogical presentation. I was more concerned with becoming familiar with the features and operations and the potential of the tool. With the necessary time at hand, highly effective pedagogy could be designed using Prezi.
Although Prezi doesn't eclipse Glogster, it is probably going to be more engaging and beneficial for students than Glogster. However, Glogster has benefits outweighing Prezi with respect to group learning, collaboration, and networking. The content can be created within a wiki-like environment where students can access the site and make their own contributions and edit existing content. In this respect, the ethical considerations pertaininng to the group 'ownership' and interaction in the site would need to be incorporated into the learning activity and design. Glogster also engages similar faculties to Prezi and is a very multi modal tool; but overall it lacks the creative potency of the Prezi, and the ability to engage the viewer in the presentation that Prezi possesses. (I have been teaching a science unit in prac with year 6s, and will encourage them to use both of these tools for an assessment project involving the design of a poster in relation to energy use in their school. The Glogster presentation I produced is more closely aligned with pedagogy for primary school learners, and I would like it to be considered in combination with my learning in Prezi for assessment purposes.)
Depending on the content of the Prezi, legal and ethical considerations are integral to its incorporation in pedagogy. Like the other technologies above, students would benefit from intellectual property and copyright instruction, as well as being aware of and adhering to privacy concerns. Similarly, in a Glogster - which would be more likely to include examples of students' personal work, for example, in a class learning journey made publically available, permissions would be required to publish this work. The most effective method for making students aware of these requirements, and ensuring as best as one can that they adhere to them, it to incorporate law, ethics and safety into the unit or lesson, and make it assessible. Further, school controls are required. Perhaps it is worthwhile considering establishing a separate unit or aspect of the curriculum which focusses exclusively on e-learning legislation, ethics, privacy and safety, considering the imperatives of 21st digital learning, as well as the reality that ICT is becoming embedded into all KLAs and subjects across the curriculum.
  • Group 4 - Google Earth
I've chosen Google Earth out of the Group 4 tools due to its ability to be applied across the curriculum, and the level of visibility it creates for learners. It could be used as a stand alone tool for pedagogy, or be incorporated as one mode of communication in multi modal products. It expands the perspective of learners, and allows them to be connected, however virtually this may be, to their world. They can delve in to their local environment and gain perspective that they couldn't have through their natural senses, and of course they can connect and view distant places and cultural artifacts globally. It is a highly connectivist learning tool. I have considered its specific learning uses a little more within this blog, but that reflection doesn't even represent a scratch on the surface of its applications for pedagogy. It would be highly engaging for learners and lends itself to scaffolded learning as I have discussed to an extent in my blog reflection.
Nevertheless, I don't see Google Earth as being effective for all learner ages. For children in the Prep - year 5 age range, tools like Museum Box and Zooburst would be more effective and suitable. Museum Box would not only develop young learners' skills in ICT applications, but would enable them to develop their skills in analysis and evaluation, as they learn to categorise and build semantic systmes out of their real life experiences. It could be used in a range of KLAs and be very stimulating and rewarding for young learners. Similarly, Zooburst has fantastic potential for yong learners' development of literacy skills, and would engage many creative faculties in the production of their own texts. (I would have liked to explore the online concept mapping tools but was unable to due to technical factors.)
The online timeline tool I explored, Dipity, has certain benefits (as outlined in my blog reflection on the tool), but as I indicated in my reflections, a timeline is innately linear and chronological, and in this wouldn't cater to the learning preferences of all students. I do see advantages in using timelines to devise a structure or framework and collate information for a presentation or product that would ultimately be situated elesewhere, but am afraid that this technology would 'enrage' rather than engage learners because of its linearity.
The biggest concern I have with Google Earth relates to privacy, and this is a concern that seems to surround this technology overall. I don't think it is the cause of the privacy concern, moreover it is a manifestation of the lack of privacy there is in modern society due to satellites and other technologies - and perhaps pernicious intents -  which make the world such a public place. The internet considered holistically does hold many dangers and creates potential and a 'field' for various social pathologies to thrive. The most productive, and perhaps, the only strategy available to teachers and parents is to educate children on the responsible use of digital technology, the advantages and disadvantages, potentials and dangers. But if digital technology is to be incorporated systematically within 21st century learning, and if it is such a key imperative, it must be incorporated responsibly and thoughtfully. The curriculum needs to include an equal focus on responsible, ethical, and safe use of this technology as it does on the development of skills in it.




An amateur digital video

I recorded a video on my daughter's iPod. Well, it recorded well, but I'm not sure it's going to upload in this blog in a hurry. Reflecting on this, I can see why, I didn't create it in MovieMaker and the format of the file is probably too large to upload. I just did a simple recording down at my local beach. I focussed on some erosion issues and explored the rocks with the video, trying to find some creatures as I had before. But the tide was high ...

Nevertheless, it helped me appreciate the value of this technology as a learning tool. It could be used across the curriculum and would support most learning styles. As I believe anyway, no one is always aligned with one or more categories of the multiple intelligences proposed by Gardner. I don't agree with the 'absolute' nature of classifying people according to theories or types. I'm often quiet, reserved and like working on my own; but other times I have a strong desire to integrate and speak my mind to others. I am a words man, but I learn very well visually also. I think the totalising impulse needs to be restrained to a degree when teaching in the classroom.

But some examples of digital video uses for learning would include field trips and excursions, where the students could identify flora and fauna, examples of natural processes, and develop presentations. Digital video would be valuable for dance, drama and music, the playback, pausing, and other features enhancing learning and effectively developing skills. It could be very useful for hearing impaired students, in teaching sign language for example.

Digital video would be suitable to so many learners because it's fun and creative. Learners are making a product they can feel ownership and pride for. When incorporated into the learning objectives correctly, it can have myriad valuable uses.

Timeline - Dipity doo daa ...

The online timeline is also a useful Group 4 technology, but I'm not convinced it would support the range of learning styles. Timelines by nature are limiting, because they are linear and chronological. This might suit sequential learners, or intrapersonal learners, but it lacks the potential to engage visual learners, interpersonal learners, kinaesthetic learners and so on. However, the online tool does allow multi modal products and is much more interesting and engaging than a non ICT-based timeline. Its potential rests I think on being used to provide a framework for a more stimulating eleaboration of the key events in relation to a them or topic. For example, the online timeline could be used to gather and house the information, including the images, videos, and other textual types added to it, but I think it would be much better to then develop a Prezi, perhaps, to make not only the presentation more engaging for an audience, but the project more stimulating and creative for the individual learner producing it. Useful, but innately status quo with no lasting value in itself.

Google Earth

Google Earth is a very useful learning tool which can be incorporated across the curriculum. There would need to be clear ethical guidelines and strict monitoring of students working on it in a school setting, and the risk of students become voyeuristic would require strict management. I can see it being a useful tool for science or SOSE with a focus on pollution. The learning could be scaffolded in the following way:

1 - Demonstrate a simple case of pollution in the local area using the tool. For example, track the following scenario through the satellite images:
- a man walks along a local street
- He drops a cigarette in the gutter
- (I have selected a street which is a few blocks away from a creek, and this creek also connects to the ocean a few blocks away)

2- Ask the students where this will go?
- Have students explore the surrounding areas to the street with Google Earth. Develop their skills in the navigation functions.
- Ask them to track a pth of the cigarette using the satellite. Prompt them if necessary. For example, it might be necessary to ask: 'What do you think will happen when it rains'?
- The idea is that they will understand that the rain will wash the cigarette down the hill along the gutter until it reaches a drain.
- Ask them where they think the cigarette will go from there. Explain where drains empty (i.e. the creek a couple of blocks away)
- Continue this process until the students realise that the cigarette will spill out into the creek, then eventually into the ocean, and consider the damage it can do to the ocean and marine creatures.

3 - Have students present the course of the cigarette on Google Earth. They can compliment the presentation with images, their own digital video footage, and so on.

4 - Now from this understanding students have gained, a larger scale project can be devised, again using Google Earth.
- Idenitify a local power station, or other source of heavy industry.
- Students will need to investigate pollution controls at the industrial site.
- If it is well controlled, have them consider the situation of a failure in control mechanisms.
- Have them trace on Google Earth the flow of the pollution type (toxic water, toxic smoke/emissions, etc), and develop a presentation incorporating information they gain from relevant research.

From this example activity, it is clear that Google Earth can be used for a broad range of educational uses (and doesn't have to be the sole tool within a project) to promote learning across a wide range of KLAs.

Glogster - Good but uses lots of energy

Well, after spending lots of time understanding how to operate in the Glogster environment, I finally put together a page on Energy. It is a very good tool, all frustration aside and can cater for different types of learners. It lends itself to group andindividual work, global or sequential learning, and its multi modal capability makes it extremely diverse and suitable to the range of different learners and learning styles. This is definitely something I will show my prac class, as they need to develop a poster. I think Prezi is more stimulating, but this is a good tool for acquiring a range of knowledge and skills. My Glogster can be viewed here.

Wednesday, April 18, 2012

Prezi - Going Deeper

Okay, like everyone else in the course, I think Prezi is very exciting as a learning tool. This technology is sure to engage learners in their learning. And after a period of instruction, it is something most learners could pick up relarively quickly. It alows students to create very attractive, multi modal presentations, and when something is created, even something fairly simple and low level like my presentation, it gives a sense of reward and success. The operations required to create the Prezi are relatively straight forward; it just builds off existing technologies already available, but the aesthetic it creates is quite remarkable.

I am currently showing some technology to my mentor teacher - the class has to design a multi modal poster for a science unit on improving school energy use. I was thinking Glogster was the technology I would show the teacher, but Prezi could be better. The students would get such a kick out of putting something together - images, text, videos, and manipulating all this with the zoom, formatting and path features Prezi affords. It can be shared easily, and would lend itself to group or individual design.

Overall, this is very impressive and valuable, I'll certainly use it. I only designed a very simple presentation with text, images, videos, and links, but with some more time could really get lost in this tool. I did have trouble with a couple of the images I uploaded; for some reason when I view the presentation these tow images can't be zoomed in on, or treated as a stand alone object in the path. So there are some teerthing problems that learners need to work through. But I'll try to revisit this and identify the problem.

Overall, Prezi more a journey than a presentation, and one the learners will most definitely enjoy. My little Prezi is here

The sharper Point - Powerpoint

The tutorials for this tool were very useful, and promote an understanding that Powerpoint doesn't have to be a boring, status-quo teaching or presenting tool. When it is used in a basic 'text on slide' way, yes, it is boring, but with the advanced operations and functions shown in the tutorials it can be put to sound pedagogical uses.

I can see benefit in incorporating Powerpoint into pedagogy for younger learners, for instance, the click and drag mechanism is a good learning tool, suitable for primary students of all ages. Some would argue older primary students are more advanced than a click and drag activity, but I am noticing with the year 6 students in my practical placement that they do engage with this type of activity - provided the content is interesting to them. Powerpoint could be used across various KLAs for this activity. The hyperlink function is valauble, in that by this the presentation can become less 'linear' and chronological, and this can disrupt the preconceived notions viewers may have of powerpoint presentations. It would certainly be useful for Prep/early chilhood settings in adding sound functions to compliment images. By associating a sound with an image and a word, such as the dog/woof/bark example, learners can gain graphophonic understanding, and develop the use of semantic cues. It would certainly be useful for a reading/literacy tool.

Also, learning how to create the structure of the presentation in Word prior to designing it in Powerpoint is not only more efficient and time saving, but it develps learners skills in a more holistic sense than simply typing text into slides within Powerpoint; it helps them understand the complex and interconected nature of computer applications.

So, Powerpoint is not as exciting or engaging to view and create as a Prezi or Glogster, but it isn't redundant or without any worth for teaching and learning either.