Friday, March 16, 2012

De Bono's Hats - Wiki Activity

I think this forum facilitated learning through constructivism and connectivism.
It reflects constructivism (primarily social constructivism) in that:
- the learning had a social basis, and the meaning and understanding I derived was promoted through the collaborative nature of the wiki. My knowledge and opinions grew as i reflected on those shared by the others in the group.
- The forum made the thinking of each member of the group visible, and without access to the perspectives of the other members my initial attitude to the issue (which was exclusively in the negative) wouldn't have been able to develop as it did. My attitude became informed ad enhanced by the group members; it was constructed through social interaction.
- A permanent record of the learning development emerged not only as artifact (the physical wiki record) but as a mentifact (the attitude i have  now gained), which is now a construct in my mind. The knowledge i gained is new and it has become internalised. This occurred through taking an active role in the learning, and the knowledge was constructed through not only my own prior beliefs, attitudes, and mental structures, but those of the group members.
- Although the group was only relatively small, an intellectual community was created, having the features of a community in that intellectual resources were shared, a common goal was implicit in the activity which we all worked towards, and the opinions of others were respected and contributed equally to the objective.
- Complex reasoning processes were involved in the activity, as the higher order thinking of Bloom's Taxonomy were engendered: analysis, evaluation and synthesis. The analysis occurred in, first - reflecting on the topic individually; and secondly, through  approaching it in the light of the others' input. The evaluation occurred through mentally collating and assessing the validity of available research, facts and opinions (including those held by the other members) so that my own understanding and attitude were enhanced and better informed; while the synthesis is the production of the new knowledge and attitude that I now have. Synthesis is also occurring now in reviewing the process here in this blog - it can be seen as the result or outcome of the learning process that the wiki activity facilitated. Finally, the scaffolded learning inscribed in De Bono's Hats as a process has analysis, evaluation and synthesis embedded within it, with these higher orders corresponding to the sequential levels: each new level built on the knowledge gained and shared in the previous level (or hat).

The activity reflects connectivism in that:
- the networked nature of the forum demonstrated that learning does reside outside of ourselves (myself), and that without having access to the knowledge ad perspectives of others, my knowledge would not have evolved -nothing new would have emerged. In this sense, Seimens' idea of the importance of the pipe (the access, or the vehicle) as being more important than what is in the pipe has visible relevance. Without the pipe, nothing would have grown in terms of my schema.
- The cycle of knowledge that connectivism advocates was apparent, in that knowledge travelled from the personal to the network, and vice versa, until both the personal and the collective were enhanced. A high level of critical thinking was required, and the ability to hold existing information up to the light of criticism was nourished. Was the group a parental network (or organisation as Seimens refers to in his cycle)? No. But, the organisation aspect could be brought in if the evolved knowledge gained from the wiki was transmitted to, or accessed by (via the pipe), a parental body or overarching organisation. Perhaps it does have this element, as it will flow in combination with the product of the other groups into the Education Faculty and the University (then back through the network to the personal).  But will it inform the issue within the school education paradigm? This is something that can"t be said for sure; nevertheless, the cycle is apparent.
- The concepts of chaos and the butterfly effect were in operation via the potency that the opinions and knowledge of each group member had for the others' learning, and the germ this provided for growth in the knowledge of the 'whole'.

There are more benefits than drawbacks to be derived from participating in a wiki like this; the benefits have been outlined in the reflections on the constructivist ad connectivist nature of the learning above. To summarise, it enhances individual knowledge through access to, and evaluation of, the knowledge of others. It grows knowledge and understanding; it promotes learning through the application of higher order thinking and complex reasoning. The scaffolded nature of De Bono's hats enabled thinking to become creative and more complex with each new hat that was put on. Learners would recognise that the personal beliefs, values and attitudes they held at the first stage of the process (hat 1) are not fixed or concrete, but that they are malleable and organic, in that these can change, expand, and develop as the subsequent hats were put on and the input of others germinated new knowledge for the individual and the whole. It was certainly a creative process, where a kind of intellectual osmosis occurred, with each tree in the field absorbing ad being nourished by the other elements in its environment.

One issue I had with the exercise was that on the second last level I felt I had already stated my position in a previous level. Perhaps a deeper analysis of the focus of each level was required on my part, or perhaps the differentiation between levels needs to be articulated better in the model itself; but irrespective of this, when teaching it to students (primary in my case) a clear and appropriate explanation of the approach to take within each level will be required. I found that by the time we got to the last 2 levels, not a lot of new critical information was coming forward, and that what was being provided by most members - myself included - was a summation or reinforcement of the very creative perspectives that emerged in the first 3-4 hats. Another issue is that I didn't have much research (on mobile phones in the classroom) to go on; that is, perhaps a period of research prior to undertaking the activity could allow for greater outcomes.

Overall, I think this was a very beneficial and effective activity to demonstrate the benefits of: collaborative, networked learning; a scaffolded approach to learning, and to promote complex reasoning about pedagogy in  learners. Nevertheless, after gaining many valuable perspectives about positive use of mobile phones in the classroom, I remain opposed to the idea and I think that resources can be better devoted to more pressing educational concerns. To close, I doubt this issue is very high on ACARA's agenda for educational reforms. 

Tuesday, March 13, 2012

Reflection on Connectivism


I think Seimen's article and the theory of Connectivism he advocates has some very valid points. I agree with the contention that much knowledge and learning resides outside of ourselves; that access to networks is essential for engendering currency of learning, and that to know more than what is already known is important. These assertions seem to be consistent with the principle of life long learning and one of the key benefits propounded for digital pedagogy\ICT - enhanced learning through collaboration and peer networks. I see value in the ideas of chaos and the butterfly effect as these highlight the interconnectedness of all things. And Seimen's metaphor of the pipe being more important than what flows in it has some merit for the consideration of the importance of learners having access to knowledge.

However, I don't agree that we should discount the importance of what is in the pipe - or suggest that what is already known and resides internally in the individual is of no value. This is because I believe that not all knowledge and learning is contingent on the external world, but that we all have innate knowledge. Furthermore, Seimen's position seems to stem from a belief that reality resides in the external, that there is an objective external reality; whereas I think reality has its locus internally, and that external 'reality' is a phenomenon - we all create and are constantly creating our cosmos, or world. My view here would seem to align with a constructivist approach to learning. 

So I can see the validity of the counter arguments regarding assessment of learners' recall of what they already know. It is critical that important knowledge is retained, for although the world is rapidly changing, many things have eduring value independent of current developments in, or the current status of, technology. Contrary to the seemingly overriding consensus on the 'permanence' of digital techology, this mode of technology, commuication and learning is not guaranteed to last forever - for history shows us that all systems break down, resources are depleted, kingdoms are overthrown or self-destruct; and digital techology can be likened to a kingdom or empire. And when this occurs, the value of what is in the pipe becomes manifest.

Therefore, although I see merit in aspects of connectivist theory, I see an inherent danger in it - the premise that all knowledge is good, and that attaining more and more knowledge is the highest good. In this, connectivist theory can be likened to a "Tower of Babel", wherein man exalts himself unto heaven.

To close my critique of the Connectivist assertion that all knowledge is good, a couple of cautionary lines from the song "Like Flies" by Government Mule seem appropriate:

       "... follow the leader to the biggest pile of sh#t ... like flies"

Monday, March 12, 2012

Multiple Intelligences

I performed the test on 2 occasions and in each test I scored highest in the Intrapersonal, Musical, Naturalistic and Linguistic intelligences; scoring lowest in Logical ad Kinaesthetic intelligences. I think this test is a little more accurate than Felder and Solomon's, perhaps because there was a greater range of response options - responses were along a spectrum as opposed to 'a' or 'b', either\or. Though, I do disagree with my relatively low kinaestheic rating, feeling that I do learn well this way. 

But overall, I think the Multiple Intelligences model is a useful tool for showing the range of ways in which people learn, and that outcomes can be enhanced by using activities that are appropriate for the individual style\s of the learner. Because a teacher wouldn't always have a breakdown of MI results for each student within the class, learning should be designed to incorporate the multiple intelligences within the model. For example, to support kinaestheitc learners activities could be based around movement or the body, and regular movement itself (e.g. stretching, walking around briefly, etc) could be incorporated into the daily routine. Similarly, activities could have a music-related theme or music could be played when students are doing activities individually or collaboratively. A naturalistic learner will perform better if activities are done outside or on excursions, or if the content relates to things in nature.


Designing activities that could cater for various styles at once would be even more effective. For example, a lesson might involve a class going on a bushwalk and after breaking into groups havig to identify different flora and fauna, and report on the details of their findigs, produce a map, etc. This would capture the kinaestheitc, naturalistic, visual, interpersoal, and linguistic learner's needs simultaeously. Or again, having groups of students design and perforfm a dance choreograhy based on the various animals in "Old McDonald's Farm" could capture the musical, naturalistic, kiaesthetic, visual, interpersoal and linguistic intelligences. I'm sure there are better examples than this, but for me the MI model reinforces the importance of holistic learning,through designing activities that incororate a range of learning styles and employs elements from various disciplies or KLAs.
Felder and Solomon - Learning Styles


According to my questionnaire results, I am a reflective, intuitive, visual and sequential learner. I scored: Reflective  - 3; Intuitive - 1; Visual - 1; Sequential - 3. This is accurate to a degree, however, I believe in some ways I am also an active, sensory, verbal and global learner. In my opinion (without fully accepting the questionnaire results) I learn best through initial explanation\instruction, a chance to read\view and reflect on the content\ task, and then through doing. I need a balance between my own reflection and contemplation, performing an activity myself, and learning collaboratively through discussion, group tasks and feedback. I believe I have an equal preference for verbal and visual learning, and while I am creative and imaginative, and like to learn concepts and ideas, i also have a strong recall of facts and theories ad often need to have clear instructions and follow a defined procedure to solve certain problems or perform certain tasks.


To support the range of learning styles in a traditional classroom of 25 students, I would first gain an understanding of the personalities, learning styles, prior knowledge and background of my students. Once this is gained I would ensure a balance between teacher instruction and student tasks, being careful not to privilege a particular learning style\s. I would incorporate tasks that require students to be both reflective or active; instruction that was both visual and verbal; tasks that require creative problem solving, and those that required adherence to a set procedure. I would allow time for individual and collaborative learning. Ultimately, I would ensure activities were stimulating, relevant and meaningful for the students. Over time, I would self-evaluate as well as use direct and indirect feedback on the level of engagement and learning that occurred and adjust my approach and activities accordingly.


Incorporating digital pedagogies will firstly make learning more interesting and engage the students to a greater degree, because it makes learning student-centred. Whether the ICT is used for individual or collaborative activities it is catering for a greater range of styles than a traditional teacher-centred approach to learning. It supports the range of learning styles in the Felder and Solomon model by requiring students to be creative; use and develop their problem solving ability; learn new processes and skills, and work collaboratively. Even if a student is a visual and reflective learner, ICT based learning will only make this more interesting as it engages more of a learner's faculties than simply listening and speaking, reading ad writing -without negating the preference for these learning styles. There are many programs that will give students of all ages an experience of success, whether this be in the form of simple or complex quests, puzzles and quizzes; creating various ICT products, or just seeing their own work in a published form. It engenders a sense of ownership in the learner; can enhance self esteem, and develop social and cultural understanding and communication skills through linking with other students locally and across distances. From my experience, all kids love computers, and from a very early age they can experience success in online and ICT programs - and the learning is often rapid. Using ICTS will automatically make the learning relevant, stimulating and meaningful for learners which will enhance learning outcomes.


From my point of view, the Felder ad Solomon model is flawed, in that there is only two responses to each question and in many cases i wanted to answer both equally. Also, the responses might be different in another sitting depending on how one is feeling at the time. Learning is dynamic and fluid, and what one prefers in one context will differ from a preference in another context. Therefore, I would keep my profile questions very broad and informal in the first instance, then I would allow a clearer assessment of a learner's style  to come over time and experience (this might only be a matter of days or weeks in many cases.) Initially I would ask the student about what they like doing, gain a basic idea of their background, and make an initial assessment of their literacy level. I'd ask if they had used computers much and what kind of things they like doing on the internet. I'd ask what sports or music they liked, and find out what they like doing on the weekends and holidays. I'd ask a little about family and friends. This information would give me an overall picture of the learner from which to start to plan content and design relevant activities. I honestly believe that the learning style of the student will become more apparent through time and experience than from performing a survey like that of Felder ad Solomon's.