Tuesday, March 13, 2012
Reflection on Connectivism
I think Seimen's article and the theory of Connectivism he advocates has some very valid points. I agree with the contention that much knowledge and learning resides outside of ourselves; that access to networks is essential for engendering currency of learning, and that to know more than what is already known is important. These assertions seem to be consistent with the principle of life long learning and one of the key benefits propounded for digital pedagogy\ICT - enhanced learning through collaboration and peer networks. I see value in the ideas of chaos and the butterfly effect as these highlight the interconnectedness of all things. And Seimen's metaphor of the pipe being more important than what flows in it has some merit for the consideration of the importance of learners having access to knowledge.
However, I don't agree that we should discount the importance of what is in the pipe - or suggest that what is already known and resides internally in the individual is of no value. This is because I believe that not all knowledge and learning is contingent on the external world, but that we all have innate knowledge. Furthermore, Seimen's position seems to stem from a belief that reality resides in the external, that there is an objective external reality; whereas I think reality has its locus internally, and that external 'reality' is a phenomenon - we all create and are constantly creating our cosmos, or world. My view here would seem to align with a constructivist approach to learning.
So I can see the validity of the counter arguments regarding assessment of learners' recall of what they already know. It is critical that important knowledge is retained, for although the world is rapidly changing, many things have eduring value independent of current developments in, or the current status of, technology. Contrary to the seemingly overriding consensus on the 'permanence' of digital techology, this mode of technology, commuication and learning is not guaranteed to last forever - for history shows us that all systems break down, resources are depleted, kingdoms are overthrown or self-destruct; and digital techology can be likened to a kingdom or empire. And when this occurs, the value of what is in the pipe becomes manifest.
Therefore, although I see merit in aspects of connectivist theory, I see an inherent danger in it - the premise that all knowledge is good, and that attaining more and more knowledge is the highest good. In this, connectivist theory can be likened to a "Tower of Babel", wherein man exalts himself unto heaven.
To close my critique of the Connectivist assertion that all knowledge is good, a couple of cautionary lines from the song "Like Flies" by Government Mule seem appropriate:
"... follow the leader to the biggest pile of sh#t ... like flies"
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


No comments:
Post a Comment